Plain dark chocolate is usually halal; milk chocolate and filled bars depend on the pack. Cocoa mass, cocoa butter and sugar are plant products. The doubt comes from the emulsifier, the whey, the filling and the flavouring, and the same brand can use a different recipe in each country.
Is dark chocolate halal?
Mostly yes. Cocoa mass, cocoa butter and sugar raise no halal question. Dark chocolate rarely contains whey, gelatin or a glazing agent. Some mass-market dark bars do add milk fat or skimmed milk powder, and some list E476, so read the emulsifier line.
Are the emulsifiers in chocolate halal?
Lecithin, E322, is halal in the forms used in chocolate. The other codes are doubtful unless the pack names a source.
E322, lecithin. Usually soy or sunflower. It can come from egg yolk, which is halal but rare in chocolate. "Soya lecithin" or "sunflower lecithin" settles the line.
E476, PGPR. Common in chocolate, where it lets makers use less cocoa butter. It is built on castor oil, but its glycerol can be animal-derived, so it stays doubtful.
E471, mono- and diglycerides. Plant or animal fat, including pork fat, and the label rarely says which. "Of vegetable origin" resolves it.
E492, sorbitan tristearate. An anti-bloom agent. Its stearate may be animal-derived.
Why does milk chocolate raise a whey question?
Milk chocolate often contains whey powder, and whey is what is left when milk is curdled to make cheese. Most commercial dried whey is rennet cheese whey, so the rennet question follows it into the bar.
If the cheese was set with animal rennet from an animal not slaughtered Islamically, the doubt travels with the whey. If it was set with microbial rennet, as a great deal of industrial cheese now is, there is no issue. The label says only "whey powder", so treat it as unresolved unless the maker says otherwise.
Is white chocolate halal?
White chocolate has no cocoa solids but plenty of milk, so the whey question comes up more often than with dark. It usually contains lecithin, and some bars add E476 as well. Treat it like milk chocolate.
What about fillings, glazes and flavourings?
When a chocolate product is clearly not halal, the cause is usually something that is not chocolate.
Gelatin, E441. It can sit in marshmallow, mousse and chewy centres. In industrial markets it is typically porcine unless the pack says beef or fish.
Shellac, E904. The glaze on small coated chocolates, secreted by the lac insect. The Hanafi, Shafi'i and Hanbali schools forbid eating insects, but Indonesia's MUI ruled shellac pure and permissible as a food additive in 2013. Views differ.
Carmine, E120. The red in coloured shells, made from cochineal insects. MUI declared cochineal colouring halal in 2011. The Mufti of Malaysia's Federal Territories does not permit it in food.
Alcohol is a separate case. Liqueur chocolate says so on the pack. Vanilla extract is made by steeping beans in ethanol and may appear only as "natural vanilla flavouring". Scholarly opinion is divided on non-intoxicating carrier alcohol, and some certifiers accept it while others do not. "Vanillin" on a label is the synthetic compound, so the question does not arise.
Is Cadbury chocolate halal?
It depends on where the bar was made.
Malaysia: Cadbury products made in the country are certified by JAKIM, and have been since 2004.
United Kingdom: Cadbury bars are not halal certified. Most plain ones contain no animal ingredient beyond milk.
United States: Cadbury-branded chocolate is made by Hershey under a licence acquired in 1988, so the recipe is not the British one.
Check the country of manufacture on the back of your pack. American chocolate is not systematically certified, so there the answer is per product.